Hindutva

Hindutva ("hinduness", coined by Vinayak Damodar Savarkar in his 1920 book of the same name) is a movement, advocating the promotion of Hinduism. It is virtually impossible to discuss Hindutva without discussing the controversy surrounding it.

The main beliefs of Hindutva are:

• The Indian subcontinent (which includes the area south of the Himalayas and the Hindu Kush, usually Pakistan, India, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, and sometimes Afghanistan) is the homeland of the Hindus.
• "Hindus" are those whose religion is indigenous to India. This includes Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs, as well as those who are usually accounted as Hindus.
• Hindus have been historically oppressed in their own land by invading forces like the Muslims and the Christians.
• Hindus have become weak over time due to the influence of British colonial and Communist thinking.
• A Hindu state must be established to protect the rights of the Hindus in their homeland.

Hindutva has always had a strong anti-Communist bent, and usually portrays Communists as conniving and manipulative of the truth. Some critics consider Hindutva as being anti-Muslim and anti-Christian, and anti-foreigner in general.

Hindutva also advances a strong critique of secularism in India, which it dubs pseudo-secularism, because of different standards for Hindus, Muslims and Christians. The subject of a Uniform Civil Code, which would remove special divorce provisions for Muslims and Christians from the Indian Constitution, is one of the main political planks of Hindutva. Followers contend that in a secular democracy, it makes little sense to allow Muslims, for example, to marry more than once, but to prosecute Hindus for doing the same. This actually seems to focus attention on an atypically controversial instance, since, in general, the Civil Code was fragmented to accommodate the considerable ethnic and religious diversity and plurality of the Indian people.

Table of contents

1 Alleged Hate Speech 2 Violence 3 Social Work

Alleged Hate Speech

Some people claim that speeches and letters distributed by Hindutva organisations incite hatred of people based on an ethnic stereotype for Muslims. Some examples of alleged hate speech by the VHP and Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh include the following (from English translations of the original pamphlets in Gujarati that have been widely circulated in Gujarat during years leading up to 2002 - [1])

• The traitorous, terrorist Muslims will come in truckloads, kill the guards and then enter the bungalows. They will kill you in your bedrooms and drawing rooms. ... Vishwa Hindu Parishad is the generally accepted powerful group of Hindus worldwide including those in our country. About 250 workers in Gujarat have left their jobs and businesses to work full time for it and it has a presence in 7,000 villages. They run 350 one-teacher schools in forest areas besides hospitals, dispensaries, refugee homes, ashram schools and thousands of centres for satsang. There are rifle-training camps and the Bajrang Dal workers are given trishuls and taught to use them.
  • signed Chinubhai N. Patel, Vishwa Hindu Parishad state leader
• Those Muslims who are against Hindus are all terrorists. ... We do not want to leave a single Muslim alive in Gujarat.
  • signed Hindu Sevak
• INSTRUCTIONS FROM LOCAL LEADERS TO RSS MEMBERS ... (9) When fighting the Muslims change the appearance of your neighbourhood so you are not recognised. ... (23) Deform new-born babies of Muslims. ... Ask all politicians only what they are doing for Hindus. If he associates with Muslims, boycott him and teach him a lesson. Explain calmly to those Hindu traders who maintain close relationships with Muslims in the hope of cheap goods that this is wrong — then warn them and if they still don't listen, cause them as much economic damage as possible
  • signed MAKE AT LEAST TEN COPIES AND DISTRIBUTE THEM

Violence

Several Hindutva organisations (notably the Vishwa Hindu Parishad and the Bajrang Dal have been associated with anti-minority (for lack of a better word) violence by groups espousing Hindutva philosophies.

The BJP, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and the Bajrang Dal have been associated with the anti-Muslim violence in Gujarat in early 2002. In the inquiry led by Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer, which led to the report Crime Against Humanity ? An Inquiry into the Carnage in Gujarat, detailed allegations claiming that Hindutva organisations actively supported the pogrom of over 2000 Muslims are presented [1].

While followers of the philosophy are rarely apologetic about violence, they do seek to rationalize it; in the case of Graham Staines, violence was excusable because of the greater violence done by conversion; in the case of the Gujarat riots, it was a justified response by outraged Hindus to the burning of 56 Hindu pilgrims in a train by a Muslim mob. In fact, several studies have been done by (arguably biased) Hindutva scholars (notably Arun Shourie and Koenraad Elst) documenting the primary causes of violent events in India, and concluding that in almost all cases, Hindus did not instigate the initial violence.

Social Work

Followers of Hindutva feel that any violence associated with their organisations is marginal, and the real work of Hindutva organisations is social service. Hindutva organisations are active in many disaster relief efforts, notably the Gujarat earthquake of 2001. They also coordinate extensive education and public health efforts amongst the tribal communities across India. These have, however, been interpreted by many to be devious efforts to gain acceptance in, and infiltrate, new sections of society.